Startups hiring their first account executive usually choose among four kinds of recruiting service. Success-fee networks and marketplaces, such as Refery and Paraform, fit when the founder needs screened candidates who have sold to a similar buyer. Fixed-fee services such as Funded.club fit when cost predictability matters more than search depth. Managed sourcing such as Wellfound Autopilot fits when you want inbound volume and can screen it yourself. Recruiters paid for their time, such as those on Dover's marketplace, or a fractional head of talent, fit when you have several open roles and nobody to run the process. None of them fixes an unclear sales motion, so the first step is the brief, not the vendor.
Refery wrote this guide and is one of the options listed. This is a buying framework, not an independent ranking. Every other provider's description comes from an existing Refery guide that quotes that provider's own website, and the checked date is shown next to each source. Published offers are provider statements, not verified results or contract terms.
What a first account executive search actually needs
A recruiter can only find the right person if the job is defined. For a first AE, three things decide most of the brief.
What the founder hands off. Founder-led sales means the founder opened relationships, explained the product, changed the roadmap or negotiated unusual terms. The founder-led sales handoff guide asks which of those the hire will own and which the founder keeps. Name the founder's continuing role in discovery, demos, negotiation and closing. If the motion is not yet repeatable, say so in the brief; the person will help build it.
Where pipeline comes from. A seller who had well-qualified inbound and demo support has done a different job from one who chose accounts and wrote outreach. Ask any recruiter to trace how a candidate's deals began, using the questions in how to assess self-generated pipeline. For a first US hire from a company selling elsewhere, the first US sales hire guide separates market learning from executing a known process.
Base, OTE and the plan behind it. OTE is base plus target variable pay under the plan, not guaranteed cash. The founding AE salary and OTE guide shows two public postings checked September 15, 2026: one lists base and OTE separately, the other lists only OTE. Keep base, variable pay, quota, ramp, pipeline and equity in separate lines of the brief.
If you are unsure whether you need a seller at all, the first GTM lead guide separates a founding account executive from a sales leader and a growth hire, and founding AE vs GTM engineer covers a common title confusion.
The service models compared
| Model | How paid | What they do | Best when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Success-fee network (Refery) | 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire | Specialist independent recruiters plus founder, operator and investor referrals, with one contact who screens and coordinates | The hire is founding or senior and you want screened context on each candidate | Search scope, who screens, candidate overlap with your own pipeline |
| Recruiter marketplace (Paraform) | Company fees not published; quoted per proposal | Expert recruiters and custom AI agents; lists go-to-market among its specialties | You need sourcing bandwidth from many recruiters at once | Fee basis, who screens, ownership terms |
| Percentage on hire (Jack & Jill) | 10% of first-year salary on hire, no subscription, retainer or upfront fee | Recruiting paid on hire; the pricing page advertises a full refund if a hire leaves or is dismissed in the first three months | You want a low published percentage | Whether "salary" means base or OTE for a seller, and role coverage |
| Fixed fee (Funded.club) | Flat fee by salary band, from $4,900 up to $21,900 above $190,000 | Fixed-fee recruiting with a shortlist guarantee | Cost predictability matters more than depth | Which salary figure sets the band for an AE, shortlist definition |
| Managed sourcing (Wellfound Autopilot) | $500 per month per role plus 10% on a successful hire | Inbound from a startup job board with a light managed layer | You can screen volume yourself | Percentage basis, monthly cost while the search runs |
| Paid for time (Dover marketplace, fractional recruiter) | Dover lists hourly, retainer and pay-per-hire options, with recruiter-specific terms | A recruiter works inside your process | Several open roles and nobody to run them | Total cost if the search runs long |
| In-house recruiter | Salary plus tools | Your own hire runs every search | Fees across a year would exceed the cost of a recruiter | Not useful for a single urgent AE hire |
Apart from Paraform listing go-to-market among its specialties, the descriptions above are general service models, not offers specific to account executive searches. Ask each provider what comparable sales searches it has run and who would work yours. If the search is really for a VP of Sales, an executive search firm such as Hunt Club, which quotes per engagement, is a different purchase.
Why fee basis matters more for an AE
For an engineer, base salary and total cash are often close. For a seller, they can differ by half.
Illustrative calculation, not a quote: take the fictional plan from the founding AE guide, $160,000 base and $160,000 target commission, so $320,000 OTE. A 20% fee is $32,000 if the basis is base salary and $64,000 if it is OTE. At Refery's 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, the same plan comes to $24,000 to $40,000.
So a lower percentage on OTE can cost more than a higher percentage on base. Ask every provider to state the basis in writing, along with the payment trigger and what the guarantee covers. The startup recruiter cost guide puts published fees on one page, and recruiting payment and guarantee questions lists the contract questions.
Where Refery fits and what it does not claim
Refery is a startup recruiting network for VC-backed Seed to Series B companies hiring Engineering, AI and GTM talent. For a founding account executive search, the brief starts with the buyer, deal size, sales cycle, current proof of demand, the founder's role and which pipeline the hire must create. Screening separates what a candidate sourced, ran, negotiated and closed from what came with a prior employer's brand or system.
Terms: 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire, no retainer, no exclusivity, 90-day guarantee under the client agreement.
Refery does not claim the lowest price, a guaranteed time to hire or universal role coverage, and this guide makes no placement or outcome claims. If your team can source and screen sellers itself, a job board or managed sourcing may be enough.
What posted ranges say about AE pay
Refery's startup salary ranges report covers public job postings from US startups collected April 12 to November 13, 2026. For account executives, labeled "base or OTE as posted":
| Group | Median posted midpoint |
|---|---|
| Account executive, all US (497 postings, 297 companies) | $240,000 |
| Account executive, Seed | $240,000 |
| Account executive, Series A | $222,000 |
| Account executive, Series B | $218,000 |
| SDR or BDR, all US (157 postings, 127 companies) | $102,000 |
The middle half of AE posting midpoints fell between $172,000 and $300,000. Only about a quarter of AE postings said explicitly whether the range was base or OTE, so these rows mix the two. They are ranges employers advertised, not salaries paid, and not a representative market benchmark. Use them to check that your posting is in a plausible range, then confirm with candidates what their number means.
Questions to ask any recruiter before a first-AE search
- What sales searches comparable to this one have you worked, and who will work ours?
- Is your fee a percentage of base salary or of OTE, and when is it due?
- What does the guarantee cover: replacement, refund or credit, and for how long?
- Is the agreement exclusive, and what happens to candidates already in our pipeline?
- How will you verify which pipeline a candidate created themselves?
- What will you tell us about each candidate's prior selling environment: buyer, deal size, inbound support and founder involvement?
- How will you confirm a candidate's compensation expectations, base and variable separately?
- Who gives feedback, how often, and what happens if early candidates keep missing the same criterion?
If you want Refery to be one of the proposals you compare, share the role, buyer and compensation plan.
Sources
Provider descriptions are copied from existing Refery guides, which cite each provider's own website. Checked dates are those of the original guides.
- Refery terms: refery.io/recruiting-fees, as published on Refery's fee page.
- Paraform (agentic recruiting model, proposal pricing): paraform.com/for-companies, checked November 13, 2026, from Recruiting Platforms for VC-Backed Startups in 2026.
- Paraform (go-to-market specialty, pricing not published): paraform.com, checked September 19, 2026, from 8 Paraform Alternatives.
- Jack & Jill: jackandjill.ai/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from Recruiting Platforms for VC-Backed Startups in 2026.
- Funded.club: funded.club/fixed-fee-recruiting, checked November 13, 2026 (fee tiers), from the same guide; shortlist guarantee checked September 19, 2026, from 8 Paraform Alternatives.
- Wellfound: wellfound.com/recruit/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from Recruiting Platforms for VC-Backed Startups in 2026.
- Dover: dover.com/recruiters, checked November 13, 2026, from the same guide.
- Hunt Club: huntclub.com, checked September 19, 2026, from 8 Paraform Alternatives.
- Founding AE postings: checked September 15, 2026, in Founding Account Executive Salary and OTE in 2026.
- Posted pay: Startup Salary Ranges in 2026, postings collected April 12 to November 13, 2026.
Public pages and terms change. Confirm scope, fee basis, payment trigger and guarantee in writing before a search starts.
Frequently asked questions
Which recruiting services help startups hire their first account executive?
Four kinds: success-fee recruiting networks and marketplaces such as Refery and Paraform, fixed-fee services such as Funded.club, managed sourcing such as Wellfound Autopilot, and recruiters paid for their time, such as Dover's marketplace or a fractional recruiter. Refery wrote this answer and is one of the options. Choose by how clear your sales motion is and how much of the search your team can run.
Should a recruiter's fee for an account executive be based on base salary or OTE?
Ask before you sign. In an illustrative plan with $160,000 base and $160,000 target commission, a 20% fee is $32,000 on base and $64,000 on OTE. Refery's fee is 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire.
What do startups post as pay for account executives?
In Refery's November 13, 2026 report of 497 US startup postings, the median posted midpoint for account executives was $240,000. These are posted ranges, not salaries paid, and they mix base and OTE because most postings did not say which they were.
Do I need a sales leader or a founding account executive first?
If founders can win customers and need someone to repeat the process, a founding account executive fits. If salespeople are already active and need coaching and forecasting, a sales manager fits. Decide the job before choosing a recruiting service.
What does Refery charge for a first account executive search?
15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire, no retainer, no exclusivity, with a 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. Refery does not claim the lowest price or a guaranteed time to hire.