There is no verified universal best recruiting platform for a VC-backed startup; the right choice depends on whether your constraint is sourcing and screening, running the process, or specialist access on a critical search. This guide compares seven options on their published models and prices: Refery, Paraform, Dover, Jack & Jill, Superposition, Funded.club and Wellfound.
Refery wrote this guide and is one of the providers below. This is a buying framework, not an independent ranking. The six competitor entries link to official pages checked on November 13, 2026. Published offers are provider statements, not independently verified performance results or a substitute for a written proposal.
Correction and substantive update: this edition replaces older descriptions that treated Dover as hourly-only, narrowed other providers' role coverage, or implied a universal best option. It removes unrechecked providers and older speed or guarantee summaries. The original publication date is preserved.
The short answer for founders and talent leaders
Choose the model that addresses your constraint. If your team can source and screen, a job board or sourcing tool may be enough. If nobody can run recruiting, compare fractional or embedded support. If a critical search needs specialist access and screened context, compare managed search services on the same brief.
For San Francisco and New York Seed to Series B searches, define the office arrangement, seniority, first outcome and compensation before requesting proposals. Product management is not product engineering; a founding seller is not automatically a sales leader; a recruiter hire is not the same purchase as outsourced recruiting.
Seven options, compared by published model
| Provider | Published model and price | What the buyer should clarify |
|---|---|---|
| Refery | Managed network of specialist recruiters and operator referrals. 15% to 25% of first-year base salary on successful hire; no retainer or exclusivity. 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. | Search scope, named contact, screening evidence, candidate overlap and applicable guarantee provisions. |
| Paraform | Describes an agentic recruiting firm combining expert recruiters and custom AI agents. Request a written company proposal for the exact fee and scope. | Which specialists work the role, who screens, fee basis, workflow and ownership terms. |
| Dover | Recruiter marketplace offering hourly, retainer and pay-per-hire options. Recruiter-specific terms apply. | Compare a scoped proposal; an advertised average cost per hire is not a quote for your role or a matched comparison with another service. |
| Jack & Jill | 10% of first-year salary on hire, with no subscription, retainer or upfront fee. The pricing page advertises a full refund if a hire leaves or is dismissed in the first three months. | Confirm compensation basis, role coverage, candidate overlap and the actual agreement. |
| Superposition | Per-hire option: $500 per month per agent plus 15% of first-year base salary on the hire's first day. Also offers a quoted flat monthly arrangement. | Number of functions and agents, duration, total monthly cost, screening responsibilities and replacement terms. |
| Funded.club | Published fixed fees by salary band: $4,900 up to $70,000; $7,500 up to $110,000; $11,500 up to $150,000; $15,900 up to $190,000; $21,900 above $190,000. | Applicable tier, payment timing, geographic and specialist coverage, shortlist definition and contract conditions. |
| Wellfound | Free job posts; optional promotion and sourcing plans. Autopilot advertises $500 per month per open role plus 10% on a successful hire. | Distinguish self-serve tools from managed recruiting. Confirm percentage basis, role duration, screening scope and additional costs. |
These are different services and risk allocations. A lower advertised fee does not prove lower quality; a higher fee does not prove better candidates. A monthly cost continues while a search runs. A success fee depends on the agreement's definition of a hire and candidate ownership.
What Refery fits, and what it does not claim
Refery's core public offering is Engineering, AI and GTM recruiting for VC-backed Seed to Series B companies. Specialist independent recruiters and founder, operator and investor referrals feed a coordinated search and screened introductions.
Product, Talent, Operations and Strategy briefs are welcome, but specialist coverage and capacity are confirmed before commitment. Refery does not claim universal role coverage, the lowest price or a guaranteed time to hire.
The approved anonymized search stories describe particular engineering engagements. They are not proof of outcomes in every function or a representative speed benchmark. In-house talent teams can use Refery alongside their own channels.
Quality: ask for evidence that changes a decision
| Check | Useful evidence | Weak substitute |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | What the candidate personally built, sold or operated | Employer logo or title alone |
| Role fit | Relevant work against the agreed outcome | Keyword overlap |
| Constraints | Confirmed location, compensation, interest and availability | Assumptions copied from a profile |
| Screening | What was assessed and what still needs testing | An unexplained score |
| Accountability | Named search owner and feedback process | A large network without clear responsibility |
Use a partner quality scorecard. Ask for a redacted example or a clearly labeled illustrative brief rather than confidential candidate records.
Cost: put proposals on the same basis
For a $200,000 first-year base salary, Refery's 15%, 20% and 25% examples are $30,000, $40,000 and $50,000. These are arithmetic examples, not a quote. Use the fee calculator for a different base.
Compare percentage basis, monthly charges, payment trigger, taxes or additional expenses, internal screening time, candidate overlap, termination and guarantee conditions. Do not compare one provider's base-salary fee with another's total-compensation fee as though the denominators match. For sales, separate base from OTE.
A useful internal model is external recruiting spend plus the hiring team's time cost. Vacancy cost can be a separate scenario, but only with company-specific assumptions. Do not treat assumed revenue per vacant seat as proven savings from a recruiter.
Speed: four different clocks
| Milestone | Definition to agree before launch |
|---|---|
| First introduction | First candidate shared after the brief is accepted |
| Qualified shortlist | Agreed number of interested candidates meeting the must-haves, with constraints checked |
| Accepted offer | Candidate accepts the company's offer |
| Start date | Candidate actually starts |
Record calendar days from an agreed search start, along with client pauses and feedback delays. Report cohort size and role mix. A provider's testimonial about one quick introduction cannot establish typical time to hire.
Agree who gives feedback and the review cadence. If initial profiles consistently miss the same criterion, fix calibration before adding sourcing volume.
Choose the next step
- Founder making an early hire: use the hiring brief template, identify the decision owner and compare two relevant proposals.
- Head of talent adding capacity: agree one search boundary, candidate overlap and the feedback loop. See support for talent teams.
- Comparing Mercor or Jack & Jill for an engineering hire: see the alternatives guide.
- Hiring a new function: confirm specialist coverage and assessment depth before agreeing to a search.
- Ready to discuss Refery: share the role, location and outcome.
Sources and review policy
Official service and pricing pages linked in the comparison table were checked November 13, 2026. Public offers can change. Confirm scope, price, payment timing and guarantee conditions directly before signing. Provider marketing claims are not used here as independent evidence of comparative quality or speed.
Frequently asked questions
Which startup recruiting platform is best?
There is no verified universal winner. Compare providers against the same role, stage, location, screening standard, total cost and milestone definitions. Refery wrote this guide and is one of the options.
Is Refery the cheapest recruiting option?
No lowest-price claim is supported. Refery's published fee is 15% to 25% of first-year base salary on a successful hire. Some providers advertise lower percentages, fixed fees or time-based services. Scope, candidate ownership and guarantee terms must also be compared.
How should we compare hiring speed?
Separate time to first introduction, qualified shortlist, accepted offer and start date. Use the same start point and show the cohort size, role mix and paused searches before comparing provider claims.