Founding account executive recruiting

Hire a founding account executive

Hire the first seller who can repeat what the founders have been closing themselves, and say honestly which parts are not repeatable yet.

For founders and heads of talent at Seed to Series B companies making the first account executive hire after founder-led sales. Start with what the founder will hand off and what they will keep.

The shortlist, with the reasoning
Ethan ChoCo-founder intro · work reviewed
A+
Ines CarvalhoSpecialist search · screened
A−
Lena BrandtScout intro · screened
A

An illustration of how a Refery search is presented. The names and grades are examples, not real candidates.

Our clients are backed by investors including:

  • Y Combinator
  • Sequoia
  • a16z
  • General Catalyst
  • Lightspeed
  • Founders Fund
  • Greylock
  • Insight Partners

Make the role clear

Decide what the job is before the search starts.

A founding account executive closes deals and helps build the motion. A sales leader coaches and forecasts for a team that already exists. A GTM engineer builds the systems around selling. If salespeople are already active and need management, this is a different search.

Put these decisions in the brief

  • The buyer, deal size, sales cycle, and the deals the founders have closed so far
  • What the founder hands off in discovery, demos, negotiation, and closing
  • Which pipeline the company supplies and which the hire must create
  • Base salary, target variable pay, quota, ramp, and equity as separate lines
The brief
Must own
The buyer, deal size, sales cycle, and the deals the founders have closed so far
Stage
VC-backed, Seed to Series B
Still open
Location, band, and the first milestone
Scope and fee agreed before the search15%

What to look for in candidate evidence

Three things a shortlist should show.

Self-generated pipeline

How specific deals began: who chose the account, who wrote the outreach, and what came from inbound or a prior employer’s brand.

Comparable selling environment

A sale to a similar buyer at a similar deal size, with the amount of founder and demo support stated.

Building, not only executing

What the candidate changed in the process after losing deals, and what they stopped doing.

A useful interview exercise. Give the candidate two anonymized deals your founders closed and one they lost. Ask what they would repeat, what they would test first, and which accounts they would approach in the first month. Listen for questions about the buyer before any claim about a forecast.

Start a search with Refery

One brief. Two networks. A reasoned shortlist.

Refery is a startup recruiting network for VC-backed Seed to Series B companies hiring Engineering, AI, and GTM talent. It combines specialist independent recruiters with referrals from founders, operators, and investors.

Refery charges 15% to 25% of first-year base salary on a successful hire. No retainer, no exclusivity, and a 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. Scope and fee are agreed upfront. See current pricing.

Send your hiring brief →
  1. Share the brief

    Send the role, location, compensation, and the outcome the hire needs to own.

  2. Confirm fit and scope

    Discuss the search, candidate evidence, interview process, and commercial terms with Refery.

  3. Keep the decision grounded

    Use a consistent scorecard, capture interview evidence, and give specific feedback as the search progresses.

Before you set the budget

Compare like with like.

Compare roles with the same responsibilities and working arrangement. Our salary guides show dated public posting examples, with base salary, equity, and variable pay kept separate.

A question hiring teams ask

Should a recruiter’s fee for an account executive be based on base salary or OTE?

Ask before you sign, because for a seller the two can differ by half. Refery’s fee is 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire. In an illustrative plan with $160,000 base and $160,000 target commission, a 20% fee is $32,000 on base and would be $64,000 on OTE.