Startup recruiting firms that publicly say they work on success fees with no retainer include Refery, Jack & Jill, Kruger Recruiting, Paraform, Recruiting from Scratch and TekRecruiter, and Dover's recruiter marketplace offers pay-per-hire as one of its options. Refery charges 15% to 25% of first-year base salary only on a successful hire, with no retainer, no exclusivity and a 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. Jack & Jill publishes 10% of first-year salary on hire. A Paraform article dated September 4, 2026 states 25% of first-year base salary on hire. Recruiting from Scratch, Kruger Recruiting and TekRecruiter say they charge a percentage on hire without publishing the number. "No retainer" settles when you pay; it does not settle what you pay on, whether the search is exclusive, or what the guarantee covers.
Refery wrote this guide and is one of the firms listed. This is a buying framework, not an independent ranking, and the others appear in alphabetical order after Refery. Each firm's terms are quoted or summarized from that firm's own website, with the checked date shown in the sources. Published offers are provider statements, not contract terms.
Seven firms, by published success-fee terms
| Firm | Published fee on hire | Retainer or upfront fee | Published guarantee | Focus the firm states |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Refery | 15% to 25% of first-year base salary | None. No exclusivity. | 90 days, under the client agreement | VC-backed Seed to Series B companies hiring Engineering, AI and GTM talent |
| Dover (pay-per-hire option) | Recruiters set their own rates; a success fee is "typically a percentage of first-year base salary, or a fixed amount" | Hourly and retainer options also exist; the page describes a refundable deposit | No replacement guarantee published | Marketplace of fractional recruiters for startups |
| Jack & Jill | 10% of first-year salary | No subscription, retainer or upfront fee | The pricing page advertises a full refund if a hire leaves or is dismissed in the first three months | AI-led recruiting |
| Kruger Recruiting | "A negotiated percentage of the candidate's annual salary, payable after the hire starts" | None stated | "A 90-day replacement or refund guarantee" | Startups and growing companies |
| Paraform | "A flat percentage of first year base salary only upon hire"; its September 4, 2026 article states 25% | None stated | A replacement search if a hire does not work out within 90 days | Recruiter marketplace across stages |
| Recruiting from Scratch | "A percentage of the candidate's first-year salary"; number not published | "No retainers, no upfront fees" | A replacement is described; period not published | Engineering roles at startups |
| TekRecruiter | Contingent; "the fee depends on the role and is agreed in writing before the search begins" | "No fee until your hire starts" | A replacement search within 90 days | Technology and engineering roles |
Firms that work the other way are worth recognizing so you do not compare unlike things. Retained executive search firms, such as Christian & Timbers and Foundry Search, are paid for the search in stages. Fixed-fee and subscription services, such as Funded.club's published salary-band fees or Superposition's monthly fee plus a percentage on hire, are neither a pure success fee nor a classic retainer. The startup recruiter cost guide puts all of these models in one table.
Five terms that matter more than "no retainer"
- The basis. A percentage of base salary and a percentage of total cash or OTE are different numbers. For a seller, they can differ by half. Get the basis in writing.
- The trigger. Is the fee due on offer acceptance, on the start date, or after a period? Kruger Recruiting and TekRecruiter state that the fee follows the start.
- The guarantee. Replacement, refund or credit are three different remedies. Ask how long it lasts and what conditions void it.
- Exclusivity. A success-fee search can still be exclusive. Refery's is not. Check what happens to candidates already in your pipeline.
- The ownership window. Most agreements say a fee is due if you hire an introduced candidate within a set period. Ask how long, and whether it covers other roles.
Recruiting payment and guarantee questions lists the full set to send a firm before you sign.
What a success fee costs in practice
Illustrative calculation, not a quote: at a $200,000 first-year base salary, 10% is $20,000, 15% is $30,000, 20% is $40,000 and 25% is $50,000. Refery's published range covers the $30,000 to $50,000 examples; use the fee calculator for a different base.
A lower percentage does not prove a lower total cost. Compare what is included: who screens, how much of your team's time each model consumes, and what the guarantee is worth. And a success fee is not the right model for every search. Should a seed-stage company use a contingency recruiter at all? This guide covers when a non-exclusive contingency search underperforms, and retainer vs contingency vs referral fees compares the three structures.
Where Refery fits and what it does not claim
Refery is a startup recruiting network for VC-backed Seed to Series B companies hiring Engineering, AI and GTM talent. Each search combines specialist independent recruiters with referrals from founders, operators and investors, and one Refery contact coordinates screened introductions.
Terms: 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire, no retainer, no exclusivity, 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. The rate is agreed before the search starts.
Refery does not claim the lowest fee; Jack & Jill publishes a lower percentage. It does not claim a guaranteed time to hire or universal role coverage, and this guide makes no placement or outcome claims.
If you want Refery to be one of the proposals you compare, share the role and compensation.
Sources
Each firm's own website.
- Refery: refery.io/recruiting-fees
- Christian & Timbers: frequently asked questions, checked November 15, 2026
- Dover: dover.com/recruiters, dover.com/pricing, checked November 15, 2026
- Foundry Search: frequently asked questions, checked November 15, 2026
- Funded.club: funded.club/fixed-fee-recruiting, checked November 13, 2026, from Recruiting Platforms for VC-Backed Startups in 2026
- Jack & Jill: jackandjill.ai/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from the same guide
- Kruger Recruiting: krugerrecruiting.com/expertise/forward-deployed, checked November 15, 2026
- Paraform: paraform.com/for-companies and how to hire a forward deployed engineer, checked November 15, 2026
- Recruiting from Scratch: frequently asked questions, checked November 15, 2026
- Superposition: superposition.ai/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from the same guide
- TekRecruiter: direct hire, checked November 15, 2026
Public pages and terms change. Confirm scope, fee basis, payment trigger and guarantee in writing before a search starts.
Frequently asked questions
Which startup recruiting firms work on success fees with no retainer?
Firms that publicly say they charge only when a hire is made include Refery (15% to 25% of first-year base salary, no retainer, no exclusivity, 90-day guarantee), Jack & Jill (10% of first-year salary on hire), Paraform (success-based; a September 2026 Paraform article states 25% of first-year base salary), Recruiting from Scratch (contingency, no retainers or upfront fees), Kruger Recruiting (percentage payable after the hire starts) and TekRecruiter (no fee until the hire starts). Dover's marketplace offers pay-per-hire as one option. Refery wrote this answer and is one of the options.
What is the difference between a success fee and a retainer?
A success fee, also called a contingency fee, is due only if you hire a candidate the firm introduced. A retainer is paid in stages for the search itself, whether or not a hire is made. Some firms combine a smaller upfront payment with a success fee.
What percentage do success-fee recruiters charge startups?
Among firms that publish a number, Refery states 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, Jack & Jill states 10% of first-year salary, and a Paraform article dated September 4, 2026 states 25% of first-year base salary. Several contingency firms say the percentage is negotiated and do not publish it. Always confirm whether the percentage applies to base salary or total cash.
Is a success-fee recruiter really free until you hire?
The fee is, but your time is not. You still brief the recruiter, review candidates and run interviews. Also check the agreement for exclusivity, candidate ownership periods and what happens if you hire someone the firm introduced for a different role.
Does Refery charge a retainer?
No. Refery charges 15% to 25% of first-year base salary only on a successful hire, with no retainer and no exclusivity, and a 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. The rate is agreed before the search starts.