Alternatives to Mercor and Jack & Jill for a startup hiring engineers include Refery, Paraform, Recruiting from Scratch, Dover, Superposition and Wellfound. They differ mainly in who screens candidates. Refery combines specialist independent recruiters with referrals from founders, operators and investors, and charges 15% to 25% of first-year base salary only on a successful hire, with no retainer. Paraform is a recruiter marketplace paid on success. Recruiting from Scratch is an engineering-only contingency firm. Dover connects you with fractional recruiters. Superposition sells AI recruiting agents. Wellfound is a job marketplace where you screen applicants yourself. Start by deciding whether you need an employee or project capacity, because Mercor's public pages describe expert staffing and AI services rather than a standard employee search.
Refery wrote this guide and is one of the options listed. This is a buying framework, not an independent ranking, and the others appear in alphabetical order after Refery. Each description comes from that provider's own website, with the checked date shown in the sources. Published offers are provider statements, not verified results or contract terms.
First, what Mercor and Jack & Jill publish
Mercor. Its public pages, checked September 19, 2026, describe expert staffing, AI evaluation delivery and enterprise AI services, with embedded specialists directed by the client or managed evaluation work priced by task. That can sit alongside an engineering team, but it is not automatically a search for a permanent employee. See Refery vs Mercor.
Jack & Jill. It pairs a candidate-facing AI agent with a hiring agent and makes introductions when both sides are interested. Its pricing page, checked November 13, 2026, advertises 10% of first-year salary on hire with no subscription, retainer or upfront fee, and a full refund if a hire leaves or is dismissed in the first three months. See Refery vs Jack & Jill.
If you are looking for an alternative, the useful question is what you want to change: who screens, how you pay, or how much of the process your team runs.
Six alternatives, by who does the screening
| Provider | Who screens | Published fee model | Fits when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Refery | Specialist independent recruiters, plus referrals from founders, operators and investors who have worked with the candidate; one Refery contact coordinates | 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire. No retainer, no exclusivity. 90-day guarantee under the client agreement. | A founding, senior or applied AI engineer hire at a VC-backed Seed to Series B company, where evidence of ownership matters |
| Dover | A fractional recruiter you select from its marketplace, working inside your process | Hourly, retainer or pay-per-hire; recruiters set their own rates | Several open roles and nobody to run them |
| Paraform | Recruiters on its marketplace, with custom AI agents | A flat percentage of first-year base salary on hire; its September 4, 2026 article states 25%. 90-day replacement search. | You want many recruiters sourcing at once |
| Recruiting from Scratch | Its own recruiters; engineering roles only | Contingency, a percentage of first-year salary; no retainers or upfront fees. Number not published. | An engineering hire on a contingency search |
| Superposition | AI recruiting agents | Per-hire option: $500 per month per agent plus 15% of first-year base salary; a quoted flat monthly option also exists | You want an AI-led process with a monthly cost |
| Wellfound | Your own team | Free job posts; Autopilot advertises $500 per month per open role plus 10% on a successful hire | Your team can source and screen applicants |
Freelance and contract marketplaces answer a different need. If you want an engineer for a defined project rather than an employee, that is a statement of work, not a recruiting search, and Mercor's staffing model may itself be the right comparison.
How to choose
Decide employee or project. If this person will own your roadmap and grow with the team, write an employee brief. If you need a deliverable or temporary capacity, write a statement of work. Do not compare a salary-based fee with a project budget as though they cover the same thing.
Decide who establishes the evidence. For a founding or senior engineer, what matters is what the candidate personally built, the tradeoffs they made and whether they would actually move. An AI match or a job board produces profiles; someone still has to establish those facts. That is either your team or a recruiter.
Put fees on the same basis. Illustrative calculation, not a quote: at a $200,000 first-year base salary, 10% is $20,000, 15% is $30,000 and 25% is $50,000. A monthly fee continues while the search runs. Confirm whether a percentage applies to base salary or total cash, and what the guarantee covers.
Run the same brief past two providers. The hiring brief template and the partner quality scorecard make proposals comparable. The broader recruiting platforms comparison and the Paraform alternatives guide cover more providers.
Where Refery fits and what it does not claim
Refery is a startup recruiting network for VC-backed Seed to Series B companies hiring Engineering, AI and GTM talent. An engineering search begins with what the engineer must build and the decisions they will own. Each introduction states the evidence for fit, confirmed constraints and what still needs to be tested.
Terms: 15% to 25% of first-year base salary, only on a successful hire, no retainer, no exclusivity, 90-day guarantee under the client agreement.
Refery does not claim the lowest price; Jack & Jill publishes a lower percentage. It does not offer contract staffing or AI evaluation services, does not guarantee a time to hire, and this guide makes no placement or outcome claims.
If you want Refery to be one of the proposals you compare, share the role and compensation.
Sources
Each provider's own website.
- Refery: refery.io/recruiting/engineering-recruiting, refery.io/recruiting-fees
- Mercor: mercor.com/enterprise-evals, mercor.com/enterprise, checked September 19, 2026, from Refery vs Mercor
- Jack & Jill: jackandjill.ai/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from Recruiting Platforms for VC-Backed Startups in 2026; jackandjill.ai/jill, checked September 19, 2026, from Refery vs Jack & Jill
- Dover: dover.com/recruiters, checked November 15, 2026
- Paraform: paraform.com/for-companies and how to hire a forward deployed engineer, checked November 15, 2026
- Recruiting from Scratch: frequently asked questions, checked November 15, 2026
- Superposition: superposition.ai/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from Recruiting Platforms for VC-Backed Startups in 2026
- Wellfound: wellfound.com/recruit/pricing, checked November 13, 2026, from the same guide
Public pages and terms change. Confirm scope, fee basis, payment trigger and guarantee in writing before a search starts.
Frequently asked questions
What are alternatives to Mercor or Jack and Jill for hiring engineers?
For a startup hiring engineers as employees, alternatives include Refery (specialist recruiters plus founder, operator and investor referrals; 15% to 25% of first-year base salary on hire, no retainer), Paraform (recruiter marketplace, success-based), Recruiting from Scratch (engineering-only contingency firm), Dover (fractional recruiters and an applicant tracking system), Superposition (AI recruiting agents on a monthly fee plus a percentage) and Wellfound (startup job marketplace). Refery wrote this answer and is one of the options.
Is Mercor a recruiting agency for startup engineers?
Mercor's public pages, as checked September 19, 2026, describe expert staffing, AI evaluation work and enterprise AI services rather than a standard recruiting search for an employee. If you need a permanent engineering hire, confirm directly with Mercor whether it supports that arrangement.
How is Refery different from Jack & Jill?
Jack & Jill describes an AI agent on each side of the hiring process and advertises 10% of first-year salary on hire. Refery uses specialist independent recruiters and founder, operator and investor referrals, with one contact coordinating screened introductions, and charges 15% to 25% of first-year base salary on hire. The practical difference is who gathers and vouches for the evidence on each candidate.
Which alternative is cheapest?
No lowest-price claim is supported across these services because they are different purchases. Jack & Jill publishes 10% on hire and Wellfound's job posts are free, while Refery publishes 15% to 25% and a September 2026 Paraform article states 25%. Compare total cost including your team's screening time, the fee basis and the guarantee.
When should a startup use a recruiter instead of an AI hiring platform?
When the hire is senior or founding, the candidate pool is mostly people who are not applying, and you need someone to establish what a candidate personally built and whether they would move. A platform that matches profiles at volume fits better when your team can screen and the role is well defined.